I cant believe he won it at all he hasnt played very well though and he is very old the top player had to be nathan ellighton from wigan he scored a hatful of goals and he terrorised defences all season and him and jason roberts were lethal together

Ok, well he has got it because he single handedly got West Ham (The Hammers) into the Play-offs without him they would not have got there. I think a player like Michael Tonge or Jobi Mcanuff ahve been consisten throughout the year, and they should have got it. Sheringham has not been consistent and hasn't even been a first team player all season.