Old Firm XI

Was having this discussion with a fella at work. If they were to make an Old Firm XI, who would you chose. I'm interested to know other peoples opinion as I feel I may be biased but here's mine:

......................Boruc

Hinkel......Cuellar.........McManus.........Naylor

Naka.......Ferguson.......Brown.........McGeady

.............McDonald..........JVoH

Rate Papac & Naylor equally so just stuck with Naylor



EDIT: How effing annoying is that filter thingy.... McManus....arrrgh!

--------------------------------------------- Boruc ----------------------------------------------------------

-----------Hinkel----------------Cuellar----------------McManus------------------------Papac

-----------Nakamura----------Ferguson---------------Brown-------------------------McGeady

-----------------------------------Boyd-------------------McDonald--------------------------

mite have charlie adam in that team and steven smith if he didnt get that bad injury.dont know much about hinkel.i would have hutton in there but he has moved on.david weir also.ill do a classic old firm XI if i can

goalkeeper-Klos
defenders-valgaren,amoruso,balde,mcnamara
midfielders-gazza,lambert,ferguson,petrov
forwards-larsson,McCoist

Maybe colour the players blue or green, depending on which side of the fence they sit - would make it nice and clear to see if anyone was being really biased!

I used to really like the flying winger Davie Cooper as a youngster, but Charlie Nicholas was a top player too before defecting to the dark side of North London.

I can't believe no one has included Kenny Dalglish!

I was talking about the current team brains!!

...where do you mention current?

Well ok, I didn't mention current in my original post but common sense should have kicked in here Spunkster. Not one of those players would make it into an 'All-Time Old Firm XI'

True but you can't take anything for granted where your posts are concerned!






I still say Dalglish

[beeeeep!]


Just to shut Sparky up...

..............Simpson

McGrain..McNeil..Greig...Gemmill

Jinky...McStay..Murdoch..Cooper

....McGrory....Larsson

Can see this leading to an argument but this is my honest effort

Still no Dalglish????????

Can't compete with Larsson or the record breaking McGrory. If Dalglish had have hit 410 goals in 408 league games then maybe then he could replace McGrory

Fair comment mate


















I'll shut up now

Boruc
Broadfoot Cuellar McManus Naylor
Adam Ferguson Brown Robson
Boyd McDonald

Reason for choosing is ive see Broadfoot play for st.mirren for many years and i know he is a good player where as hinkel for celtic seen him play only a handful of games.

Good point mate. I just put Hinkel in because he has looked good so far and Im a tad bit biased

I was pondering over Broadfoot, but went for Hinkel as he looks a good player.

Can't believe you haven't included either McGeady or Nakamura though G Man!

Reasons for not choosing both is because:

1. Nakamura = I dont like cheats + Robson has did more this season for Dundee United than Naka has for Celtic and since coming to Celtic Robson already has scored v Barcelona
2. McGeady = he chose ireland over scotland that i wont ever forget plus was brought up we Charlie Adam and he is doing very well

Ah but you see it's the best XI players regardless of their nationality of choice. Some would say that's borderline racism


EDIT: Shoken Speelan

If thats how you feel fair enough