Newcastle United, are reportedley dertermined to snap up goal ace striker Andy Johnson from Crystal Palace. I think this would be a great signing for them. What do you think ?

Would be the perfect signing for the geordies, hope they get him!

Played well for Palace but i do not think he is of the class to replace Alan Shearer in the long term!

agree with the general , he may have scored 20 goals for palace but 10 of those were penalties.
He will have to score 25+ each season if he wants to be in the same league as shearer .

Dont think he is top class!

Can take a great penalty!

Never world class!

Not good enough for Newcastle!

He will again be a championship player next year! If someone takes him it will be a mid table side!

Siomeone will definetly take him up, a great player and hes prove it !

I Think it'll be a brilliant signing for Newcastle.And i hope we get him.

Newcastle asking for a striker like shearer is like united asking for a keeper like Schmeichel. not possible

true, but with the geordies behind him he could have another good season, but maybe 12-15 goals as The greatest modern striker Alan Shearer will take the penalties.

P.s: I am not a Newcastle Fan

Kevin Keegan: " Ill tell you right now ill beat" (alot of finger Pointing)

He has scored tons of penaltie, half of his tally are penalties, hes not a class player, he wouldnt be great for Newcastle, he will be a premierhsip player though, maybee a mid table side!

if he went to a side where he got decent service he may score more goals from open play.

I dont think he is good enough for us.

He wouldnt score as many goals for us , theres only one man who would take our penaltys and thats big Al !