Reply to topic

Goal of the Month - August
Mido v Liverpool
0%
 0%  [ 0 ]
Ricardo Fuller v Aston Villa
72%
 72%  [ 8 ]
Deco v Wigan
18%
 18%  [ 2 ]
Kieron Richardson v Tottenham
9%
 9%  [ 1 ]
Total Votes : 11

 
  • Ben91
  • Senior Pro
  • Joined: 06 Sep 2007
  • Posts: 4130
  • Location: Warrington . . . . . . . Supports: Liverpool . . . . . . . . . Favourite Player: Sami Hyypia
Reply with quote
I have to agree with J-Axe. Brilliant goals can simply be moments of individual brilliance, but i think it can also be a peice of team brilliance. Particularly the passes right before the goal have to be taken into consideration in my view. If you pull off a sensational chipped one-two and volley into the top corner it has to be deemed better than say a corner and a volley. Or 5 or 6 one-touch passes that sythe through a defence for a neat finish has to be considered a great goal too.

Nevertheless, it's something you really have to decide upon.

Oh, and just a little suggestion on Aussie_Liverpool_Fan's suggestion - maybe people could nominate a top 10 in no particular order, and the 10 with the most votes go into the poll. If people nominate one goal, isn't it basically just voting for their favourite and technically the person with the most nominations should win anyway (although it wouldn't work out exactly like that, as people who voted for goals that didn't make the cut would have their votes free).

 
  • J-Axe
  • Current Member of the Month
  • Joined: 30 Jan 2006
  • Posts: 8388
  • Location: Belfast, Ireland
Reply with quote
As Cesc says, "A pass that makes a goal, can be as good as a goal."

With most goals, they wouldn't have been goals if it weren't for the build up play or the assisted pass. So it should all be taken into consideration.

 
  • Johaldo8
  • Senior Pro
  • Joined: 15 Sep 2006
  • Posts: 4195
Reply with quote
Yeah, Conner's just had a Frank Spencer moment there. Forgive him Smile

 
  • Sticky T
  • World Class
  • Joined: 26 Jul 2006
  • Posts: 9486
  • Location: Near LONDON Supports:Real Madrid, Liverpool
Reply with quote
-Dave- wrote:
Butt's was quite good as well I think.


Yeah me too. I was a real classy finish. It looked like the sort of goal Henry would score when he was full of confidence, because of the way his body was positioned to hit it hard and low, but he then changed it at the last minute, and floated it over the 'keeper in such a classy way. I was surprised the commentators didn't get more excited about it. I'm sure if Henry scored it they would've.

 
  • Bluenose
  • Banned
  • Joined: 17 Oct 2006
  • Posts: 9922
  • Location: Merseyside Supports: Everton Hates:Liverpoo
Reply with quote
Johaldo8 wrote:
Yeah, Conner's just had a Frank Spencer moment there. Forgive him Smile



Hmmmm betty! Wink

 
  • conner99
  • Admin
  • Joined: 05 Apr 2005
  • Posts: 18164
  • Location: Near Essex : Supports Arsenal
Reply with quote
Johaldo8 wrote:
Yeah, Conner's just had a Frank Spencer moment there. Forgive him Smile



hmm betty .. Wink Well i guess you all have a point , but its just that whenever i have watched Match of the Day they never mention anything about the team play when doing the goal of the month competition . It is not called `team` goal of the month . The actual `goal` is the thing that matters ..an example is if a team ..Liverpool .has a lightning counter atttack and a cross is floated into the box ...up jumps Pter Crouch to head the ball ...however it hits him on the shoulder and goes in the net ....goal . Now would you all qualify as a goal of the month because of the superb movement leading up to it .. ?

Another example is a defender makes a tackle on a player heading towards goal , the ball is deflected to a midfielder ..who blast the ball 25 yds into the net ....great goal or not much cop because the shot was only the result of a deflection ...

To me the goal is the deciding factor ....not how we got to it ...the player is the one who is going to win the award ....not the team ...

 
  • J-Axe
  • Current Member of the Month
  • Joined: 30 Jan 2006
  • Posts: 8388
  • Location: Belfast, Ireland
Reply with quote
conner99 wrote:
Johaldo8 wrote:
Yeah, Conner's just had a Frank Spencer moment there. Forgive him Smile


hmm betty .. Wink Well i guess you all have a point , but its just that whenever i have watched Match of the Day they never mention anything about the team play when doing the goal of the month competition . It is not called `team` goal of the month . The actual `goal` is the thing that matters


Conner, who won the BBC MOTD Goal of the Season last year?

Rooney_79586.shtml'>Wayne Rooney.

Why? Because it was a great counter-attack and great team play up to the goal which was comfortably finished by Rooney.

Was it a better strike than van Persie's screaming volley against Charlton, that gave us a 2-1 away win? No. They voted it the winner because 1.) they're biased, 2.) they went for team play, despite forgetting the fact that the team play for the van Persie goal was also better!

 
  • CFCBhoy
  • Moderator
  • Joined: 13 Feb 2007
  • Posts: 4747
  • Location: Éire
Reply with quote
If Arsenal had won the league then Van Persie would have got it

 
  • J-Axe
  • Current Member of the Month
  • Joined: 30 Jan 2006
  • Posts: 8388
  • Location: Belfast, Ireland
Reply with quote
Aye, but he should have got it regardless.

 
  • conner99
  • Admin
  • Joined: 05 Apr 2005
  • Posts: 18164
  • Location: Near Essex : Supports Arsenal
Reply with quote
J-Axe wrote:
conner99 wrote:
Johaldo8 wrote:
Yeah, Conner's just had a Frank Spencer moment there. Forgive him Smile


hmm betty .. Wink Well i guess you all have a point , but its just that whenever i have watched Match of the Day they never mention anything about the team play when doing the goal of the month competition . It is not called `team` goal of the month . The actual `goal` is the thing that matters


Conner, who won the BBC MOTD Goal of the Season last year?

Rooney_79586.shtml'>Wayne Rooney.

Why? Because it was a great counter-attack and great team play up to the goal which was comfortably finished by Rooney.


Was it a better strike than van Persie's screaming volley against Charlton, that gave us a 2-1 away win? No. They voted it the winner because 1.) they're biased, 2.) they went for team play, despite forgetting the fact that the team play for the van Persie goal was also better!


ok fair enough if that is how they choose it , i want to make sure we all understand how to narrow down the goals we nominate .. i guess it has to be a good goal as well as the build up ...like i said i dont think a simple tap in would qualify ..

 
  • pt89
  • Grass Roots
  • Joined: 22 Aug 2006
  • Posts: 378
  • Location: Bratislava, Slovakia
Reply with quote
elano,diaby or van persie

 
  • JeZZlee
  • Young Pro
  • Joined: 30 Aug 2007
  • Posts: 1108
Reply with quote
Ronaldo vs Wigan

 
  • Forev
  • Legend
  • Joined: 03 Nov 2005
  • Posts: 15179
  • Location: :noitacoL
Reply with quote
JeZZlee wrote:
Ronaldo vs Wigan


Nothing special. One pass from Pique set Rooney through and he squard it to Ronaldo for an easy tap in.

Good flowing goal but not a contender.

 
  • conner99
  • Admin
  • Joined: 05 Apr 2005
  • Posts: 18164
  • Location: Near Essex : Supports Arsenal
Reply with quote
pt89 wrote:
elano,diaby or van persie


has to be goals from october ...please indicate the matches if you can as it makes it much easier for us to remember the goals then .

 
  • Pokerkings01
  • Young Pro
  • Joined: 01 Dec 2006
  • Posts: 2112
  • Location: Surrey no less.
Reply with quote
Van Persie against Sunderland/Gordon so far for me.

Oh how I wish Chopper was still around.

 

Manu vs Wigan

  • jjj
  • Grass Roots
  • Joined: 29 Sep 2007
  • Posts: 21
Reply with quote
Tevez 's goal was fantastic......superb skill and sccuracy of the shot!!!!
A great buy for the team....let hope he can keep up the good work!

 
  • pt89
  • Grass Roots
  • Joined: 22 Aug 2006
  • Posts: 378
  • Location: Bratislava, Slovakia
Reply with quote
conner99 wrote:
pt89 wrote:
elano,diaby or van persie


has to be goals from october ...please indicate the matches if you can as it makes it much easier for us to remember the goals then .


so then just RVP against sunderland - first goal

 
  • rkredslfc
  • Young Pro
  • Joined: 14 Aug 2006
  • Posts: 2498
  • Location: Melbourne, Australia
Reply with quote
elano, diaby and van persie are the pick so far.

 
  • J-Axe
  • Current Member of the Month
  • Joined: 30 Jan 2006
  • Posts: 8388
  • Location: Belfast, Ireland
Reply with quote
Diaby scored in September. Confused

 
  • Ben91
  • Senior Pro
  • Joined: 06 Sep 2007
  • Posts: 4130
  • Location: Warrington . . . . . . . Supports: Liverpool . . . . . . . . . Favourite Player: Sami Hyypia
Reply with quote
conner99 wrote:
Johaldo8 wrote:
Yeah, Conner's just had a Frank Spencer moment there. Forgive him Smile



hmm betty .. Wink Well i guess you all have a point , but its just that whenever i have watched Match of the Day they never mention anything about the team play when doing the goal of the month competition . It is not called `team` goal of the month . The actual `goal` is the thing that matters ..an example is if a team ..Liverpool .has a lightning counter atttack and a cross is floated into the box ...up jumps Pter Crouch to head the ball ...however it hits him on the shoulder and goes in the net ....goal . Now would you all qualify as a goal of the month because of the superb movement leading up to it .. ?

Another example is a defender makes a tackle on a player heading towards goal , the ball is deflected to a midfielder ..who blast the ball 25 yds into the net ....great goal or not much cop because the shot was only the result of a deflection ...

To me the goal is the deciding factor ....not how we got to it ...the player is the one who is going to win the award ....not the team ...


Well, i don't think goals that have amazing build-up play but to be finished by a deflection or flukey way can be nominated. It has to be a combination, i.e. fantastic flowing football finished with a clean strike would suffice (it doesn't have to be a magnificent strike, as the overall goal is what it'd be voted for, rather than an individual peice of play). So either that, or an amazing goal by a single player. One or the other really.

But i do prefere the individual peices of brilliance - for example, using the goals J-Axe mentioned with Rooney and Van Persie. Rooney's was a fantastic bit of team play, but Van Persie's volley was out of this world, and those sort of goals are very rare to come by.

I guess a lot of it's personal preference.

The FF.co.uk Goal of the Month
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
All times are GMT + 1 Hour  
Page 3 of 19  

  
  
 Post Reply  

advertisement