He is.

Gerrard may get in the team because he's better than Carrick and Hargreaves but I don't think the team would be better off. Scholes is ahead of him still.

I, like the majority of people (even Man U fans) disagree with that. Scholes isn't as good as he once was, and i for Gerrard is quite clearly better than him now. Mentally Scholes would be well ahead of him in that Man U team, but that hasn't stopped Anderson leaving Scholes on the bench for a lot of this season.

Let's not forgot as well that Man U often play with 3 central midfielders. Gerrard would easily get in there.v

I don't care, though, it's never going to happen, and most people would say Gerrard is far superior to anyone you have in the centre.




I think Harry Kewell is a better winger than Ronaldo.

You should write a book. I'd buy it.

That was a brilliant analogy.

I too think Kewell would hobble into United's first team.

Haha, thank you.

Don't mention it.

Arsenal's best season in the CL was when they changed their formation and went more defensive. Coincidence? I think not.

Let's hope the Red Army are marching proud once again in Moscow eh?

Wrong

Aston Villa 4-4-2
Liverpool 4-3-3/4-5-1
Bolton 4-4-2
Derby 4-4-2
Portsmouth 4-4-2
Lyon 4-3-3/4-5-1
Fulham 4-4-2
Newcastle 4-4-2
Lyon 4-3-3/4-5-1
Arsenal 4-3-3/4-5-1
Man City 4-4-2
Tottenham 4-4-2
Portsmouth 4-4-2
Tottenham 4-4-2
Reading 4-4-2
Newcastle 4-4-2

It's a matter of opinion. I wouldn't swap Scholes for Gerrard, I'd have Gerrard at United but he wouldn't be ahead of Scholes. The only thing that Gerrard has on Scholes is age.

Anderson hasn't left him on the bench for a lot of this season, Scholes was injured Anderson only plays if Scholes is rested or we're playing 3 in midfield.

That's absolute [beep!] and you know it. How about tackling? Gerrard must be about 1000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000x better at tackling than Scholes. The same can be said about heading. He's faster, stronger, has more stamina, better finishing, scores more, better long range shooting, better at set pieces, and better at running.

Only has age over Scholes my arse!

Both Gerard and Scholes are dirty when tackling

Good result for Liverpool, we were lucky to draw 1-1.

And can someone pass my thanks onto Nicholas Bendtner for the goal line clearance, helped us out in a tight spot

that's certainly a world class touch.. he might wanna consider to switch his position to defence

That complete idiot. If I get anywhere near him, I might wanna strangle him...
He could've jumped out of the way, but for some reason, he wanted to touch the ball... Stupid ****

lucky you're not somewhere in europe.. otherwise i might've reported you to 911

not sure if i could wish you a win for the second leg.. what about a 0-0 draw?.. happy enough?..

Absolute nonsense. Gerrard may JUST creep into the United squad as a fringe player. The facts speak for themselves, Liverpool and Gerrard in particular have been OWNED by the United midfield in recent matches between the sides.

As for harry Kewell. No comment except LOL.

I didn't want a win for the second leg. I want Arsenal to go through to the semis. So how about you wish for atleast a 2-2 draw??? Please???

well that was a dissapointing result .. we should have won that quite comfortably ....2-1 or 3-1 . The incident involving Hlebb and Kuyt was in my opinion a clear penalty . This opionion is backed up by replays showing the faces of a few Liverpool players looking anxious towards the referee ....ie as if he is going to give a penalty ....etc I dont think Hlebb was `looking for it` he had just burst through into the penalty box and only a small tug would be needed to put him off ...which is what Kuyt did . The fact the referee was only yards away is also baffling ...he had been ok up till then .

I think the shot by Fabregas that Bendtner blocked on the line was ruled out for offside anyway . We had a few other chances we should have done better with ....Van Persie , Eboue ....Walcott was unlucky with his effort that flew just wide .

Flamini could have cleard the ball better just before Liverpool`s equaliser , still Gerrard showed his class with a good run and cross for Kuyt to score ..

Van Persie .....damn , Wenger must be cursing his luck ....looks like he will be out for both the League match on saturday and the 2ng leg next tuesday ..

It is not all over though ....a 1-0 win at Anfield would see us through .. we have the ability ...Liverpool have the advantage but ....game still on ...

Mate i'll always back up Harry Kewell because I know what he can do and what he can't very well having watched him play for many many years. But to say he is better than Cristiano Ronaldo makes you and Kewell and everyone who has ever defended him to the end look bad, people might link us with that stupid comment you've made...so for his, yours and Socceroo/Harry Kewell fans in general sakes.

DO NOT BRING IT UP AGAIN

Kind Regards,
AussieguywhoknowswhatheistalkingaboutwhenitcomestoAustralianfootballmattersunlikestickyt

I think Sticky was being sarcastic guys....

As for Scholes v Gerrard debate - take it elsewhere please. This is a topic about the game last night.

anyone know the latest on RVP? i cant find it anywhere

He is still gaining match fitness, he isn't injured again thats why he only got 45 minutes this morning.