It would be kind of funny if the Young Player of the Year was older than the Player of the Year...

Is it just me or are those nominations a bit generous to certain individuals? I don't think Fabregas, Gerrard, Adebayor, Richards, Young or Agbonlahor have done enough to get on either list. Off the top of my head i'd have Mascherano, Flamini and Ferdinand in the senior award ahead of the aforementioned trio.

Agree with you there Ben.

Those three definitely should be on the list. Bias to the attacking players per usual though!

tbh i think its going to be ronaldo for both

Torres for me but that git Ronaldo will probally win it.

Ronaldo has had the best season a player has had in a long time no way Torres should win. Torres has had an excellent season granted but Ronaldo has had an absolutely brilliant season.

Hold on a second, do you not support United?!

I'd have Falamini ahead of Fabregas. I've change a few names there. I'd definitely have Kranjar in the young list. Where is he? He's better than Agbonlahor.

Yeah good call, Kranjcar has been emmense for Pompey this season.

If you think Man U would be affected if Ronaldo left then pick him ,if you don't think they would loose their current position in the league then pick David James.
Simple as that.

Young player should go to ronaldo if regardless if he's younger than 22yrs.

wel said

Indeed, but i seem to recall he doesn't like Ronaldo very much.





What?

simple as

are you deaf!

alright alright for he mentally challenged i will simplify the comment.

In other words Ronaldo has a supporting cast the enables him to do what he has done this year this year.
I know that concept might be over the head of a few here but whatever.Do you think if Ronaldo was on a side like Fulham he would be top scorer? I'm guessing most intelligent people wouldn't think so,but in perspective Saha was top of the league while at the incredibly average west London team so he's proven himself as a top player without a incredible team around him. Obviously ronaldo would never be on an average team ever,but the closest you can get is Portugal.So after he wins this iffy award judge him and his greatness in how he performs in big euro games.You could say the big perm games as well,but everyone ignores that for some reason.

Ronaldo will most likely win both..

If had my way, after his performance today, I'd give it to Mr. Andriy V r nin.

LOl, Portugal average...

Only a final and two semi finals in the last 4 major tournaments... Is there any nation with a better record/more consistent record than that in the last 4 major tournaments?

haha, what about kuyt

Ronaldo should win both, he's added 37 goals to his tally so far, and that's just 5 goals behind Torres & Adebayor combined together (their Premier League goals).

Naw... Hasn't scored all game. V r nin in there for 5 minutes and we have one.

You can't combine Premier League goals of two players and produce anything worthwhile by comparing it to another players' total tally.

Ronaldo has hardly scored more than Torres in reality, considering that the Portuguese takes penalties (scoring 5 in total (although i'm not sure whether that's solely in the Premier League or in all competitions)). Torres doesn't, and if he did (or Ronaldo didn't) he would be just a couple of goals off Ronaldo.

I'd be interested to see either players' assist tally (not that i think Torres has more).

Just went through a quick look for you Ben. In all competitions, Torres has 4. Ronaldo has 7.

Just take 1 off each to get their total in the league.