its all good, going on past seasons i would have him in but his form hasnt been as high this year.

Im manager i pick

Steely he would be top goal scorer at West Ham with 9 goals

so would that make him the best centre back in the premiership?

For defending and scoring goals yes.

He has did well for Everton and also coming into the england team this season. So for that a loan he would be in my Prem 11 this season

ok mate, thats your opinion.

Hes not scoring them as a centerback tho, hes playing fullback or left mid, and as a makeshift striker at the end of games.

He has been playing Centre back also aswell as full back or left mid or a makeshift striker. So that makes him suited for my team. Has scored plenty goals from corners. Dont no any other defender who has scored as many as him. Always good know that your gonna get goals from your defenders also

when you have ronaldo, torres and Rooney, who needs a defender that is not the best at defending but can score the odd goal

dont confuse him with logic Jack

If you seriously believe that he's been the best left midfielder in the league this season... Well, I just don't know what to say really... I always see the odd person mention him in relation to good performances but I have to just assume that you're doing this off of highlight reels, I never really see City fans who watch him week in, week out raving about him. He can be very wasteful on the ball and whilst he may conjure up the odd moment of class, other times he just looks average. City have had a big problem with him this season in regards to defence, he often leaves his full back isolated and bogged down when the other team break. He's a decent player but he's not been the best left winger in the league.

And a side note, how can anyone put Vidic in their first XI but not put Rio in? Outside Ronaldo, Ferdinand has probably been United's player of the season....

Anyway, I'm going off this season.

----------------------------James

Sagna----------Ferdinand------Vidic-----------Evra


Ronaldo--------Fabregas----Gerrard------Young

---------------Torres------Berbatov/Adebayor

I'd maybe favour Berbatov as he has a better number of assists.

Cech

Sagna Ferdinand Terry Toure


Ronaldo Gerrard Nani Giggs


Torres Drogba

Fair enough. Admittedly i haven't seen that many full Man City games. I've seen a fair few though, and he has impressed me in them. Maybe it's coincidental. He has also looked good in the highlights. I don't think it's illogical to say he has been up there with Young (who you think has been the best this season).

Anyway, i like your team. I agree or was very tempted to put in every player you've included.

Another great post. Quantity again Steely.

My logic is fine. I feel Lescott has did very well this season. My opinion

Why havnt you put your best 11 of this season?

Dont want people to question you like you have me?

-----------------VD Sar


-----Ferdinand-----Terry------Vidic

---------------------Barry
-----------Gerrard
------------------------Scholes

----Ronaldo-Torres-Berbatov-Rooney

I think you have that the wrong way around. I was about to start shouting at people putting in Rio & leaving out Vidic.

Are you ossie ardilles?

might be martin jol, u know he liked his forwards.

when you have that front 4, why the hell would you need more than 3 defenders i predict that team would score atleast 27 goals against derby

derby beat us

derby beat us