I tried searching but couldn't find one.

Probably going to be a quiet summer for United this one. The only player we desperately need is a goal scorer (not that we aren't going to win the league and Champions League without one) and potentially a right back because Neville is injured and Brown isn't that good. I guess on top of that there's a chance of a new Goalkeeper to replace Van Der Sar.

As for players leaving I can't see to many in that department either perhaps Feltcher and even Saha but that would leave us needing two strikers instead of one.

Realistic Summer Activity

Karim Benzema - Quick, strong, good in the air. Labelled as the next Zidane but reminds me of Cantona. Lyon would sell but would want a lot of money but considering what we spent last year and how little activity we will carry out this year I could see us dropping 25-30m on this kid. He's scored a lot in Europe (including that cracker against us) and in the French League.

Klaas Jan Huntelaar - The real successor the Ruud Van Nistelrooy. Not much in terms of pace, solid in the air but he's the kind of player who spends 60% of the game in the opposition penalty area. Has scored bucket loads in Holland in a weaker Ajax team (73 goals in 89 games) and would surely score plenty for us, considering the chances we create. We need someone to play through the middle and lead the line. Huntelaar would be a good choice. Avaliable for between 15-20m I would guess.

David Villa - I would guess the least likely of the three possiblities but Villa is not without his charm at all. Lightning quick and a good finisher. A little lightweight and weak in the air for us imo. We already have fast players what we need most is a poacher and an aerial threat as a second option, when the passing isn't going so well. Probably cost about 15m.

Hopefully we will see ManUcho back from loan to Panathanaikos to supplement the strike force.

I would like to see better cover for the centre half positions as we appear more vulnerable with either Vidic or Rio out of the side.

Hargreaves seems to be doing ok at RB.

Pique should get a bigger role next year I think.

I'm not a big fan. I don't think he's good enough at this level. He needs to improve a lot and I have the impression that SAF isn't 100% convinced about him.

He won't buy a keeper that I'm sure of. Ben Foster will get his chance next year and he's the successor to vds anyway.

A striker and defender I think are all we need really.

There's no way you will get Benzema this summer. Lyon aren't prepared to sell, and he isn't prepared to leave. Not a hope in hell of anyone signing him just yet.

I can't see you signing Villa either. I don't think he would be the right player for you, and i don't think he would choose Man Utd if Arsenal, Liverpool or a handful of other teams came knocking.

I can see you signing Huntelaar though. Unfortunately. I want him!

Benzema recently signed a new deal with Lyon, don't see him being sold this summer.

Villa has stated he wants to play for Arsenal or Liverpool. There is also word that Real Madrid have prepared to offer 30 million + Julio Baptista for him. There is also word now that Barcelona might enter the chase for him.

Huntelaar is who I most want anyway so it's all good.

Oh and has Benzema really been compared to Zidane? He's nothing like Zidane. He's a striker, Zidane is a midfielder. Benzema is more like Ronaldo (the real Ronaldo).

Villa - Already stated he wants to play for Arsenal or Liverpool and if they dump him, he'll play for Madrid

Benzema - Will stay in Ligue 1 for one more season

Huntelaar - I don't think he'll go to United as they already have lots of attackers and there wouldn't be place for an inexperienced player like him

How about Maldini like the Larsson loan deal?

It seemed off base to me too. He's Algerian, French and good, I guess that's enough for the media nowadays.

I think it is more a physical comparison rather than a style of play.

We have one proper forward. That is Saha who is always injured. Huntelaar isn't that in-experienced either he's 24, a Dutch international and has played in the Champions League many times.

Don't be silly.


I think Man U could get on fine without signing another striker. Half the time they play Ronaldo up front anyway, and with ManUcho next season, they should have plenty of options.

With a better right-back it'd be hard to find a fault in United's defence. I think that should be their aim, as Brown isn't up to the standard of Evra, Ferdinand and Vidic. The weak-link.

Then it's an out-and-out striker if they feel necessary. I'd get rid of Saha myself, as with Tevez, Rooney, ManUcho and another striker you'd have more than enough, and the Frenchman is far too injury-prone.

I'm not sure if Giggs could do with replacing too. Nani will probably overtake him next year, starting most on the wing unoccupied by Ronaldo, so he could probably suffice as cover.

The only real area i think will be needed to be addressed is right-back. Elsewhere if strengthened is a bonus on an already strong foundation.

What so none of you want Luis Antonio Valencia.?

Liverpool and United are supposed to be fighting it out for him aren't they. I'd have him yeh, but not sure about the price that's been quoted of £10m. Apparently United have priced us out anyway... if there's any truth in this that is.

There is a rumour that United have already agreed terms with Jose Bosingwa, the Porto RB.

Boswinga agent denies deal:

I actually rate Valencia. Far too good a player for Wigan.

But doesn't it seem like a bit of a coincidence that the first time United have ever shown interest in any Wigan players we have to play them on the last game of the season?

Hard to say how good a player like Valencia is as he's playing for Wigan. I'm indifferent to us signing him.

I think hes a good player aswell but why would he want to go to a club where he isnt likely to play that often. Supposedly Man U want to trade Saha for him.

Which is a load of crap. Because Saha would be playing for ... Wigan. I wonder if Ferguson consulted him about this proposed move?

If he has a fantastic game against United at the weekend though he'll be dead set to join i'd imagine.

Saha might be injured all the time but he is far too good for Wigan.

Well i reckon if ManU do sign Valencia it will only be to enable Ronaldo to move to a more central position which would mean they would have Tevez, Rooney and Ronaldo as strikers next year so i dont see them going for a striker like Huntelaar in the summer, especially with Frazer Campbell coming back, he could do a turn if given the right oppertunities. Maybe Valencia could replace Giggs too since hes losing form and doesnt appear to ahve too long left as a key player in the squad.